Cardiac Pathology in SUDEP Compared With Sudden Arrhythmic or Traumatic Deaths
Although cardiac pathology has been postulated as an underlying cause of mortality in SUDEP, few studies have assessed the presence and severity of cardiac fibrosis in such cases.
There does not appear to be a higher prevalence of cardiac fibrosis among patients with sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) compared with patients with autopsy-defined sudden arrhythmic death (SAD) or traumatic death, according to a study published in Neurology.
Using data from the Postmortem Systematic Investigation of Sudden Cardiac Death (POST SCD) study, researchers identified 541 sudden cardiac deaths among adult patients (mean age 62.8 years, 69% men). Each heart was weighed, and ventricular and atrial orthogonal dimensions were obtained. In order to compare the prevalence of cardiac fibrosis in SUDEP vs other syndromes, investigators performed quantitative cardiac fibrosis analyses on SUDEP (n=12), SAD (n=90), and trauma (n=57) cases.
A total of 25 (4.8%) SCD cases involved epilepsy (mean age 56.4 years±15.4 years, range 27 to 92 years; 67% men), according to independent review by 2 epileptologists. Mortality was attributed to either possible SUDEP (n=10), SUDEP/definite SUDEP-plus (n=8), or other causes (n=7).
In the adjusted analysis of the autopsy-defined SAD (n=285) comparison group, the researchers found that the SUDEP cases demonstrated significantly less gross and histologic evidence of cardiac pathology for coronary artery disease (P <.0024), cardiac mass (P <.0011), interstitial cardiac fibrosis (P =.013), and total cardiac fibrosis (P =.022). The severity of interstitial cardiac fibrosis and total cardiac fibrosis was similar between SUDEP patients and trauma patients.
The overall small sample size as well as the variance in subgroup sample sizes represent substantial limitations of this analysis.
The researchers suggest that higher cardiac abnormality frequency seen in cases of SUDEP “may relate to the direct or indirect effects of seizures or antiseizure drugs on cardiac tissue, the mechanisms that cause SUDEP, or they may be unrelated to seizures, medications, or SUDEP.”
Devinsky O, Kim A, Friedman D, Bedigian A, Moffatt E, Tseng ZH. Incidence of cardiac fibrosis in SUDEP and control cases. Neurology. 2018;91(1):e55-e61.